Resistance
in Swimming
Frontal Resistance
Resistance can be a swimmer's greatest ally or greatest downfall.
Frontal resistance occurs when the body rides too low in the water, producing
a large surface area that pushes against the water in the direction opposite
of forward motion. Until the Australians began their first period
of dominance in the 1950’s, swimmers thought the best way to reduce frontal
resistance was to keep the body completely flat, riding on top of the water,
in an effort to hydroplane.2 According to Cecil Colwin, the
most effective way to reduce frontal resistance is rolling the body from
side to side with the stroke, known commonly as body roll. Another
cause of frontal resistance is lifting the head to high in the water while
breathing, swimming or both. Not only does the greater area of the
face catch water, but it also causes the lower body to sink.3
It is generally accepted that the first step in becoming a good swimmer
is dealing with the effects of frontal resistance.
Skin Friction
Skin friction is the kinetic friction of the swimmer's skin and suit with
the water. This can be easily dealt with a couple of ways.
The most popular method is to shave off all visible body hair, occasionally
even the eyebrows, and cover the body with a generous layer of lotion.
When a swimmer shaves their body hair they decreases the surface area of
their skin. The velocity of the water at the point of contact is
0 m/s. The lower the surface area the less water there is traveling
at 0 m/s.2 This is usually reserved for important
races, for example Lenny Krayzelburg did not shave in the Olympics until
the final race of his events. Megan Quann did not even shave for
the U.S. Olympic Trials, saving it for the 2000 Olympics. The effectiveness
of shaving and lotioning is still under debate. James Counsilman
believes that the results are more because of tapering (a gradual decrease
of distances and an increase in concentration on technique in practice)
before a competition and the added psychological influence of the skin
being more sensitive and smooth. There are also studies that show
shaving can take up to one second off a swimmer's time for every fifty
meters.
Another way swimmers reduce skin friction is through the use of compression
and body suits. These suits are designed to reduce muscle wobble
and most of the friction caused by the suit. The introduction of
body suits at the 2000 Olympic trials produced a new way to reduce skin
friction. The manufacturers of these suits claim the specially designed
suits reduce almost all surface friction with specially treated fabric
and seams. The effect these suits will have on the swimming world
will not be determined until much more research can be done.
Eddy Resistance
Eddy resistance is the last form of resistance that is important.
This is caused by poor stroke technique and riding too low in the water.
(see
picture) Water is unable to fill in instantly behind the swimmer,
causing them to pull water and air bubbles along with them. Eddy
resistance is also how a swimmer moves through the water. When
a swimmer's hand enters the water a bound vortex forms around the swimmers
hand and arm. In the distance events the vortex is shed only as the
arm exits the water. In a sprint event the experienced swimmer sheds
a vortex every time the hand changes direction along the lateral axis,
usually two to three times per stroke. The multiple shed vortexes
allow the sprinter to accelerate throughout the pull while still maintaining
an adequate amount of efficiency. A shed vortex is a form of kinetic
energy that occurs during an increase in velocity or a dramatic change
in direction. When it is shed out of phase the energy is wasted obtaining
another bound vortex.2 Bound vortexes formed around
the hand, arm, feet, and legs create the resistance in the water that the
swimmer uses to propel them forward.
A swimmer producing
all three forms of resistance.
http://wings.ucdavis.edu
|